AccountCraft Journal
Email Marketing Consent in Shopify: Collect, Record and Honor It
How email marketing consent works in Shopify: the four consent states, checkout and New Customer Accounts opt-ins, double opt-in, and keeping records you can show.

Email marketing consent in Shopify is a per-customer setting that says whether you may send promotional email. You collect it at checkout, through a newsletter form or in New Customer Accounts, Shopify stores it with a timestamp and source, and your sending tools must honor it. You can also let customers change that choice themselves from their account, which keeps your records current without support tickets. AccountCraft adds that self-service layer to New Customer Accounts with a privacy consent block and no code.
TL;DR
- Shopify stores email consent as one of four states (subscribed, not subscribed, pending, unsubscribed), separate from SMS.
- Order confirmations are transactional. Promotional email needs a marketing opt-in, and the rules differ by country.
- Collect consent at checkout, on sign-up forms and in New Customer Accounts, and use double opt-in where the law or your risk calls for it.
- Keep source exports and timestamps, because a customer CSV is only a snapshot.
- Compliance stays your responsibility. Shopify and apps help you collect, record and honor consent.
Table of Contents
- What email marketing consent means in Shopify
- Which rules apply to you
- Where customers give consent in Shopify
- Double opt-in: when it is worth it
- Let customers manage consent themselves
- Keep records you can show
- A short example
- Our perspective
- Add consent to New Customer Accounts
- FAQ
- Sources
What email marketing consent means in Shopify
Marketing consent is permission to send promotional messages. Shopify keeps a separate preference for each channel: email, SMS and WhatsApp. An address collected for an order confirmation, a delivery update or an account-security message is not automatically permission to send a promotion.
That split matters in practice. System notifications fire on order and fulfillment events whatever the marketing state. Marketing sends through Shopify Email, Shopify Flow or connected apps should check the customer’s consent field first. Misclassifying a promotional message as transactional is what gets stores into complaints.
The four consent states
Shopify’s customer record uses four email marketing states in its Admin API: subscribed, not subscribed, pending and unsubscribed. Pending usually means the customer started to opt in but has not yet confirmed through double opt-in. Treat pending as “do not send campaigns.”
For email, the record also holds the date and time consent was last updated and, when available, where it was collected. Neat Digital’s 2026 audit guide notes that SMS and WhatsApp keep their own state and source, so one customer can be subscribed to email and not to SMS.
Which rules apply to you
The legal test depends on where your customers live, not just where you are. Compliance is your responsibility, and this section is orientation, not legal advice. For a specific situation, ask a privacy lawyer.
| Region | Rule in short |
|---|---|
| United States | CAN-SPAM is opt-out: you can email without prior opt-in but must honor unsubscribes |
| EU | GDPR plus national ePrivacy laws: opt-in, no pre-ticked boxes |
| Germany | Double opt-in is effectively expected |
| UK | PECR: opt-in for individuals, with a soft opt-in exception for existing customers |
| Canada | CASL: opt-in, with implied consent for a limited period after a purchase or inquiry |
| Australia | Spam Act 2003: opt-in, and a one-off purchase is not enough |
The table summarizes this overview of email marketing laws. Shopify’s own June 2026 guidance agrees that opt-in is not required in the US but is required under GDPR, and recommends a checkbox and/or double opt-in at checkout or account creation. Shopify’s Help Center also states that the merchant is responsible for making sure opt-in methods follow regional laws such as GDPR, CAN-SPAM and CASL.
In practice, many stores with international traffic use one opt-in standard for everyone rather than maintaining a different flow per country. For a broader look at regional privacy duties, see this overview of global data privacy standards.
A recent EU development
A November 2025 CJEU judgment, analyzed by Freshfields, confirmed that when the ePrivacy soft opt-in conditions are met, no separate GDPR legal basis is needed. It also held that a free newsletter with a commercial purpose can count as direct marketing. If you sell to EU customers, document which basis you rely on for each list.
Where customers give consent in Shopify
Per Shopify’s Help Center, customers can subscribe in three main ways:
- A newsletter sign-up form on your store.
- A marketing checkbox at checkout. Consent is captured when they select it and continue.
- An opt-in when they sign in to their customer account.
Configure checkout consent
In the Shopify admin, go to Settings > Customer privacy and open the Marketing section. Shopify’s customer privacy settings page describes two controls: “E-mail and SMS marketing at checkout” to confirm preferences during checkout, and “Double opt-in for marketing” to confirm contact details. You can choose whether the checkbox is preselected and in which regions. For EU customers, leave it unticked by default.
Account sign-in opt-in
Shopify added an email opt-in checkbox on the storefront sign-in and account screen in 2026. A May 2026 update summary says customers who check it join your subscriber list automatically, and that the setting sits under checkout settings. Check the current option names in your admin, since Shopify changes labels often.
Double opt-in: when it is worth it
Double opt-in sends the new subscriber a confirmation email, and they are subscribed only after clicking the link. Shopify’s guidance says that confirmation email should not contain marketing content. For stores in Germany, Shopify adds a checkbox in Notifications settings to require customers to confirm their subscription.
The Italian data protection authority has called double opt-in a minimum standard of protection, according to a 2025 legal analysis. Beyond legal comfort, it gives you a cleaner list and a stronger record. Our guide to Shopify double opt-in covers deliverability and proof of consent in more depth.

Let customers manage consent themselves
Collecting consent once is half the job. The other half is making withdrawal easy. Regulators in the EU expect withdrawing consent to be as easy as giving it, and an unsubscribe link in each email is only one route.
New Customer Accounts is Shopify’s current account system, and merchants are moving to it from legacy customer accounts. Its default pages show limited marketing controls. With AccountCraft you can add a privacy consent block and an SMS consent block to the account page using the Block Builder, so customers see and change their choices where they already manage their details. Because it uses official Shopify extensions and customer privacy APIs, the customer’s choice is written back to Shopify, not to a separate database.
For the build steps and wording, see our guides to adding account consent without code, the GDPR checkbox for New Customer Accounts and consent UX design.
Keep records you can show
If a customer or regulator asks how you got someone’s consent, you need more than a yes in a column. Under Australia’s Spam Act, for example, the sender must be able to prove consent, including who consented, when and how.
A practical routine, adapted from Neat Digital’s audit checklist:
- List every place you collect consent: checkout, footer form, popups, account page, imports.
- Assign each to one channel and check the wording beside the checkbox.
- Test that pending contacts cannot receive campaigns.
- Test unsubscribe routes in Shopify and in every connected email tool.
- Keep untouched source exports in a restricted folder.
- Let the channel consent state, not a tag, decide who is eligible to receive a send.
The customer CSV from Customers > Export includes an Accepts Email Marketing column, but it is a snapshot with no original wording or signup route. Power Commerce recommends keeping a timestamp or event log of when and where customers opted in, and flagging ambiguous records for reconfirmation. Never convert unknown contacts to subscribed during a migration. Our walkthrough on exporting consent records shows the steps.
Shopify also provides tools to access, edit and delete customer data, which help merchants respond to GDPR requests for access, rectification and erasure.
A short example
Say you run a store selling to the US and Germany. A German customer checks out and leaves the box unticked: not subscribed, so no campaigns. Later she signs up through your footer form with double opt-in: pending, then subscribed after she clicks the link, with a timestamp and source. Six months on she opens her account, switches the email preference off in the privacy consent block, and Shopify shows her as unsubscribed. At every step your flows read one field, and your record matches what she chose.
Our perspective
Most consent problems we see described come from the same gap: consent is collected at one moment, usually checkout, and then the customer has no easy place to review it. We built AccountCraft around the idea that the account page is that place.
Since customer data stays in Shopify, with no separate customer database, there is one source of truth for your flows and your records. Customers can view and edit their information, and merchants can show privacy and SMS consent blocks next to it, so a preference change is a click, not an email to support.
Consent tools help you collect, record and honor choices through Shopify’s customer privacy APIs. The legal judgment stays with the merchant, and we think the best way to exercise it is to make the customer’s choice visible and easy to change.
Ivan Signorile
Add consent to New Customer Accounts
AccountCraft has a free plan, and the paid plans, Pro and Plus, are billed through Shopify. Check the Shopify App Store listing for current pricing. Its 14 block types include privacy consent, SMS consent, an update form and single fields bound to customer metafields, and you can show blocks conditionally by customer tag, market or account age, so EU customers can see different wording than US ones.

Install AccountCraft free from the Shopify App Store and add your first consent block in minutes, or see the plans on our site.
FAQ
Do I need consent to send marketing email to US customers?
Under CAN-SPAM, the US rule is opt-out, so prior opt-in is not required, but you must honor unsubscribes. If you also sell to the EU, UK or Canada, those customers fall under stricter opt-in rules. Many merchants use one opt-in standard for everyone.
Is an order confirmation email marketing?
No. Order confirmations and shipping updates are transactional and do not need marketing consent. Promotional content added to them can change that, so keep them separate from campaigns.
Where do I see a customer’s email consent status?
Open the customer’s profile in the Shopify admin under Customers to see their email marketing status. You can also export the customer list and read the Accepts Email Marketing column, remembering it is only a snapshot.
Can customers withdraw consent from their account?
Yes, if you give them a place to do it. With New Customer Accounts you can add a privacy consent block through AccountCraft so customers update their preferences themselves, and the change is saved in Shopify.
Sources
- CustomerEmailMarketingState, Shopify Admin GraphQL
- Shopify Help Center: collecting customer contact information
- Shopify Help Center: understanding customer privacy settings
- Shopify Help Center: data privacy and legal compliance for email
- Shopify Help Center: using Shopify to help comply with GDPR
- Shopify blog: opt-in email list building
- Neat Digital: Shopify marketing consent audit
- Email marketing laws overview
- Freshfields: CJEU ruling on marketing email
- Lexology: Italy marketing privacy consent
- Shopify May 2026 updates
- Power Commerce: marketing consent on the account component
- Global data privacy standards for businesses