All articles

AccountCraft Journal

New vs Classic Shopify Accounts: What Changes in 2026

New Customer Accounts vs legacy customer accounts on Shopify: sign-in, features, customization, migration steps and what to check before you upgrade.

10 min read

Shopify’s New Customer Accounts are the version every store is moving to, and what Shopify used to call classic accounts are now called legacy customer accounts. New Customer Accounts use passwordless sign-in, add features legacy accounts never had, and are customized through apps and blocks instead of theme code. If you want account pages that show your own customer data, wishlists and consent options without touching Liquid, you can install AccountCraft free from the Shopify App Store after you upgrade.

AccountCraft
apps.shopify.com
Customize Your New Customer Accounts
Add personalized data fields, wishlists, and consent management to Shopify customer accounts without coding or theme alterations.
Install free

TL;DR

  • Legacy customer accounts are deprecated: no feature updates or technical support, and a final sunset date is to be announced.
  • New Customer Accounts sign customers in with a one-time 6-digit email code, not a password.
  • Legacy theme customizations do not transfer, so rebuild them before you upgrade. You can revert within 30 days.
  • Customization now runs through app blocks and customer account UI extensions, which theme updates do not break.
  • AccountCraft has a free plan, and paid plans (Pro, Plus) are billed through Shopify. Check the App Store listing for current pricing.

Table of Contents

The difference in one table

The comparison below follows Shopify’s own feature comparison page.

Area Legacy customer accounts New Customer Accounts
Sign-in Email and password One-time 6-digit email code, no password
Shop sign-in Enabled manually Automatic for Shop Pay stores and for Shopify, Advanced and Retail plans
Social sign-in Not available Google and Facebook
Registration Separate register page or account invite None: a new email creates a customer in admin
Profile edits Customers contact you Customers edit name and email themselves
Saved payment methods, returns, store credit, Buy again Not available Available
B2B and Markets Not supported Supported
Order history and saved addresses Yes Yes
Status Deprecated Current version

That last row matters most. Shopify’s changelog says legacy accounts are no longer offered to new stores or to existing stores not already using them, and Shopify will stop providing feature updates and support.

How sign-in changes for your customers

With legacy accounts, a shopper creates a password, forgets it, and requests a reset. New Customer Accounts remove that loop. The customer enters an email, receives a 6-digit code and is in. Shopify’s Help Center says sessions persist for up to 365 days, so returning shoppers are not asked to sign in constantly.

Two practical effects for you:

  • No registration step. Anyone can sign in, and a new email creates a new customer record in your admin. Expect more customer records than before.
  • Self-serve profile edits. Customers click their initials, then Profile, to update their name, email and shipping addresses. Under legacy accounts they had to write to you.

Shopify also added marketing consent collection to the sign-in page on March 23, 2026, per its customization options page. Customers can change marketing preferences later from their profile.

What you can and cannot customize

This is where most merchants hit surprises. Legacy accounts were customized by editing Liquid templates such as account.liquid, login.liquid and register.liquid. Shopify’s developer team says those templates will eventually be locked and then removed.

New Customer Accounts work differently:

  • They are managed independently from your theme, so theme updates do not affect them, according to the upgrade guide.
  • You can edit logo, colors, fonts and a brand image in the checkout and accounts editor.
  • The sign-in page does not take customization blocks, and hiding built-in elements is not supported.
  • Apps extend the order index, order status and profile pages, or add full pages, through customer account UI extensions. These work only on the new version.
  • You cannot set a custom domain per market for account pages. One domain covers all markets.

Shopify’s customization options page lists four routes: built-in features, App Store apps, custom apps with UI extensions, and headless builds on the Customer Account API. For most merchants the App Store route is the practical one.

Where AccountCraft fits

AccountCraft is a Shopify app with a visual Block Builder for New Customer Accounts. It uses official Shopify Customer Account UI Extensions, so there is no code and no theme change, and customer data stays in Shopify with no separate customer database. It offers 14 block types: text, banner, button, card, update form, single field, record list, SMS consent, privacy consent, wishlist, image, video, spacer and divider.

In practice that covers the things legacy pages often held:

  • Editable fields bound to customer metafields, for example a birthday or preferred size.
  • Repeatable record lists, such as pets or vehicles.
  • A built-in wishlist.
  • Conditional display by customer tag, metafield, market, B2B status or account age.
  • Translations for multilingual stores.

For a deeper walkthrough, see our guide to customizing Shopify accounts and the breakdown of what you can change in the account page layout.

How to upgrade to New Customer Accounts

Shopify’s upgrade guide describes the process. Here it is as steps, with where each goes wrong.

  1. List what your legacy accounts do today. Open your theme code editor and note any customized account, login or register templates. Shopify says legacy customizations will not transfer, so this list is what you rebuild. Include apps that depend on legacy Liquid pages: they will not work on the new version.
  2. Check integrations. Review loyalty, subscriptions, returns, B2B and single sign-on. Migration guides such as Instasupport’s recommend a named replacement and a rollback step for each. Our page on whether Shopify apps work with New Customer Accounts helps with the app check.
  3. Rebuild custom fields and pages. In Shopify admin, go to Settings > Apps and sales channels, install your account app, and build the pages you listed. With AccountCraft you add an update form or single field block and bind it to a customer metafield, so no theme edits are needed.
  4. Upgrade. In Shopify admin go to Settings > Customer accounts and choose the upgrade option for New Customer Accounts. Legacy URLs such as /account/login redirect automatically to the new accounts.
  5. Test as a customer. Sign in with a real email, confirm the code arrives, open the profile and each custom block, and place a test order.
  6. Watch the 30-day window. You can revert within 30 days. That window does not restore deleted login modals or reverse DNS changes, as Instasupport notes, so make the switch the last step, not the first.

Our migration walkthrough goes deeper on the same sequence.

Existing customers and imported customers

Because new accounts use email codes, customers imported from another platform do not need a password. Latori notes that under legacy accounts imported customers sit as disabled until invited to set a password. Under New Customer Accounts they just sign in with their email.

Imported customer sign-in in legacy and new accounts

If you use Shopify Flow, note that the Customer account enabled trigger runs only the first time a customer signs in to the new accounts, and Customer account disabled is not supported. Segment statuses of disabled, invited or declined change to enabled when customers sign in.

Plus, B2B and single sign-on

Shopify B2B cannot use legacy accounts. New Customer Accounts can connect to any OAuth 2.0 and OpenID Connect identity provider for single sign-on, and existing Multipass integrations on Shopify Plus continue to work after the upgrade. If your store is on Plus, read our guide to Plus customer accounts and B2B. Teams planning an identity setup may also find this case study on locking down a site with OAuth2 useful for the authentication side.

If you sell to customers in the EEA, UK or Switzerland, Shopify’s Data Processing Addendum says you must obtain consent and give customers a way to withdraw it. Shopify acts as processor, and consent duties stay with you as the merchant.

AccountCraft helps here with a privacy consent block and an SMS consent block that help collect, record and honor customer consent through Shopify’s customer privacy APIs. Compliance remains your responsibility, and this article is not legal advice, so talk to your lawyer about your specific obligations.

One data point to know: per Shopify’s Managing customers page, an erasure request removes name, email, phone and address and passes the request to installed apps, while the profile and order history remain. Profiles with orders, subscriptions or undelivered gift cards cannot be deleted.

Is the new version limited?

New Customer Accounts were built around app blocks rather than templates, so the way you extend them is different, not smaller. Shopify’s roadmap on its customer accounts developer page lists the 365-day sign-in, sign-in page customization in the editor, and a design refresh shipped in 2026, with Sign in with Apple and post-sign-in customer fields planned for later. More than 800 apps have already adopted customer account UI extensions, per Shopify’s community post cited above.

If you are planning the broader move carefully, a general platform migration plan is a good template for preserving custom flows and preparing a rollback.

Our perspective

Merchants often treat the upgrade as a loss: the old account page had their fields, their layout, their quirks. We see it the other way. New Customer Accounts move customization out of fragile theme code and into official extensions, which is why a rebuilt account page survives theme updates.

We built AccountCraft so the rebuild is a visual task. Fields bind to customer metafields, consent sits in blocks, and the data stays in Shopify. Start with what customers actually use: edit details, view lists, manage consent. Then add a wishlist or conditional blocks once the basics work.

The upgrade is also an opportunity: when customers can manage their own data, fewer requests reach your inbox, and the account becomes a reason to return.

Ivan Signorile

Start with the free plan

AccountCraft has a free plan, and the paid Pro and Plus plans are billed through Shopify. See the App Store listing for current pricing. You can install it, build your first account page and see it in your New Customer Accounts before you commit to anything else.

AccountCraft

Install AccountCraft free from the Shopify App Store, or read what the plans include.

FAQ

Are classic accounts the same as legacy customer accounts?

Yes. Shopify renamed classic customer accounts to legacy customer accounts and deprecated them. The current version is called New Customer Accounts, and it is where all new features land.

Can I switch back after upgrading?

Yes, within 30 days of upgrading, according to Shopify’s upgrade guide. Rebuild and test your customizations before the switch, because some changes, such as deleted login modals, are not restored by reverting.

Do my customers need to create a new password?

No. New Customer Accounts use a one-time 6-digit code sent by email, so there is no password to create or reset. Existing legacy URLs redirect to the new sign-in.

Do my custom account fields carry over?

No. Shopify states that legacy customizations do not transfer. Recreate them in an app that uses customer account UI extensions. In AccountCraft, fields are bound to customer metafields, so the data stays in Shopify.

Sources