accountcraft Install free
All articles

AccountCraft Journal

Custlo Alternatives for Shopify New Customer Accounts

Comparing Custlo alternatives for Shopify New Customer Accounts: what each type of app does, where AccountCraft fits, and how to pick without breaking your store.

11 min read

If you are looking at Custlo alternatives, the first question is not which app has the longest feature list. It is what you need your account page to do. Custlo positions itself as a broad customer account suite. Other apps focus on one job, such as profile fields, consent, login or a full replacement of the account experience. This guide compares the main options, shows where AccountCraft fits, and gives you a way to test any of them before you commit.

We build AccountCraft, so we are one entrant here. We cover the others as fairly as public information allows, and we flag what you should confirm on each app’s own listing.

AccountCraft
Build a More Flexible Shopify Account
AccountCraft lets you customize Shopify New Customer Accounts with a no-code Block Builder, while customer data stays in Shopify.
Install AccountCraft

TL;DR

  • Custlo, per its Shopify App Store listing, is a wide account suite. If you only need editable customer data, wishlists and consent, a focused builder is often enough.
  • AccountCraft is a no-code block builder for New Customer Accounts. It has 14 block types, fields bound to customer metafields, repeatable lists, a built-in wishlist, conditional visibility and translations.
  • Customer data stays in Shopify with AccountCraft. There is no separate customer database.
  • No app makes a store GDPR compliant. Compliance stays your responsibility as the data controller.
  • Install on a development store or a theme copy first. Migration to New Customer Accounts is not a simple toggle.

Table of Contents

Why merchants look for a Custlo alternative

The reasons we hear most often are practical:

  • Scope. A suite that bundles loyalty, store credit, upsells and chatbots is more than some stores need. You pay attention and setup time for features you will not use.
  • Data location. Some merchants want every customer attribute to live in Shopify metafields, with no copy elsewhere.
  • Consent handling. Stores selling into the EU or California need account-level consent controls tied to Shopify’s own privacy APIs.
  • Fit with a specific job. B2B portals, pet or vehicle records, and region-specific content each need something different from a generic dashboard.

None of these makes Custlo a bad app. Its listing shows a strong rating and a long feature list. They are reasons to compare before you install anything on a live store.

First, understand what you are customizing

Every app in this category works on top of Shopify’s New Customer Accounts. That is the current account system, and legacy customer accounts are what merchants are moving away from. Shopify has said legacy accounts are deprecated, and stores created from February 2026 are restricted from using them. A final sunset date for existing stores had not been confirmed in the sources we reviewed, so check Shopify’s own announcements.

The key technical fact is where the pages live. New Customer Accounts are hosted by Shopify, not rendered by your theme. Legacy .liquid template edits are ignored, and customizations must be rebuilt with Customer Account UI extensions. Any app you consider should be built on those extensions. That keeps it inside Shopify’s sandbox and means it should not break when your theme changes.

A second fact surprises people. Shopify community discussions describe the move as a migration to a new architecture rather than a setting change. The same thread notes a 30-day window to revert, and that reverting restores the setting but not the customizations you removed. So audit your old account customizations first: loyalty portals, wholesale access, custom forms.

The main types of alternatives

The Shopify App Store has dozens of customer account apps. Rankbase tracks how the store ranks them, and directories such as FixMyStore’s list of Custlo alternatives group them by use case. Most fall into four types.

Full account suites

Custlo sits here. Its listing describes order history, profile editing, custom fields, order tracking, store credit, reordering, upsells and a long list of integrations. If you want loyalty features and post-purchase offers inside the account page, a suite is a reasonable fit. The trade-off is breadth: more to configure, more to review for data handling.

Account replacement apps

Apps such as C:Hub Customer Accounts aim to replace the default Shopify account experience with their own customizable one. Check carefully how each handles login and where customer data is stored, because that determines how much you depend on a third party.

Login-focused apps

KwikPass is an example of an app built around phone-first or OTP login and pop-ups. That is a different problem from editing account content. If your main pain is sign-in friction, start here. New Customer Accounts use a passwordless email-code login by default, which some older customers find confusing, so plan for support questions either way.

Apps like Extended Profile Fields and AccountCraft extend New Customer Accounts with custom fields, consent controls and translations, with data stored natively in Shopify. This is where we compete most directly, and where the differences are smaller and worth checking.

Comparison at a glance

This table summarizes what each type does best. Verify details on each current listing, since apps change often.

Criterion Custlo (suite) Account replacement apps Login-focused apps AccountCraft
Main job Broad account dashboard with loyalty-style extras Replace the default account experience Easier sign-in and capture Build account pages from blocks, edit customer data, manage consent
Built on Customer Account UI extensions Check listing Check listing Check listing Yes, official extensions only
Custom customer fields Yes, per listing Varies Rarely the focus Yes, bound to customer metafields
Repeatable records (pets, vehicles) Check listing Varies No Yes, record list blocks
Built-in wishlist Check listing Varies No Yes
Conditional content Customer segments, per listing Varies No By customer tag, metafield, market, B2B and account age
Consent controls Check listing Varies Not the focus Privacy consent and SMS consent blocks
Separate customer database Check listing Check listing Check listing None, data stays in Shopify
Pricing See listing See listing See listing Free plan, Pro and Plus billed through Shopify

What AccountCraft does

AccountCraft is a visual Block Builder for New Customer Accounts. You assemble the page; you do not code it or touch your theme. There are 14 block types:

  • Text, banner, button, card, image, video, spacer and divider for layout and content
  • Update form and single field for editable customer data
  • Record list for repeatable entries such as pets or vehicles
  • Wishlist, built in
  • Privacy consent and SMS consent for permission controls

Fields are bound to customer metafields, so what a customer types lands in Shopify, where your flows, segments and exports already read it. There is no second database to secure, audit or explain in your privacy policy. For more on the field side, see our guide to custom fields in Shopify accounts.

Visibility rules let you show a block only to certain customers: by customer tag, metafield, market, B2B status or account age. A wholesale customer can see reorder notes while a retail customer sees a wishlist. Translations cover the multilingual storefronts that many US merchants also run.

We do not claim AccountCraft covers everything a suite does. It has no store credit engine, no chatbot and no upsell tooling. If those are on your must-have list, a suite is the more honest answer. If your list is editable data, a wishlist, consent and tailored pages, you should not need to carry the rest.

What AccountCraft does — overview diagram

This is where wording matters. Shopify’s Customer Privacy API is the official route for reading and changing consent inside account extensions. An app that uses it can help you collect, record and honor consent through Shopify’s privacy APIs. AccountCraft does this with its privacy consent and SMS consent blocks.

What no app can do is make your store compliant. Under Shopify’s Data Processing Addendum, you act as the data controller, and Shopify does not advise you on your legal obligations. Be wary of any listing that promises compliance. If you have a specific question about GDPR, CCPA or your own data practices, ask a privacy lawyer or your data protection officer.

If you want the practical admin side, our posts on adding account consent without code and CCPA steps with the Customer Privacy API walk through it.

Consent and privacy: what an app can and cannot do — overview diagram

How to choose: a short checklist

Work through these in order and most decisions become obvious.

  1. List what your current account setup does. Open your theme code and your installed apps. Note every loyalty portal, wholesale gate and custom form. This is the audit the Shopify community stresses before migrating.
  2. Separate must-haves from nice-to-haves. Editable fields, consent and wishlist are one bucket. Store credit, upsells and chat are another.
  3. Confirm the app uses Customer Account UI extensions. The listing or developer docs should say so.
  4. Ask where the data lives. Metafields in Shopify, or a vendor database? The answer affects your privacy documentation.
  5. Check the permissions it requests. Customer account extensions use declared capabilities, so you can see what an extension is allowed to do.
  6. Test with real accounts. Use a development store or theme copy, then sign in with a test customer and walk through the passwordless flow.
  7. Check current pricing on the Shopify App Store listing. Prices and trial terms change, so do not rely on a blog post, including ours.

On timing, Rankbase advises that the decision should follow the functionality you need rather than a wish for a modern look. If your legacy setup still does everything you need, test the replacement in a staged environment before you switch.

Setting up AccountCraft step by step

Here is a typical first run on a development store.

  1. In the Shopify admin, go to Settings > Customer accounts and confirm New Customer Accounts are selected.
  2. Install AccountCraft from the Shopify App Store and open it from Apps in the admin.
  3. Create the customer metafield definitions you want to collect, under Settings > Custom data > Customers, for example a birthday or a preferred size.
  4. In the Block Builder, add an update form or single field block and bind it to the metafield.
  5. Add a wishlist block, and a record list if customers keep repeatable items such as pets or vehicles.
  6. Add a privacy consent block, and an SMS consent block if you text customers.
  7. Set visibility rules, for example showing a wholesale card only to customers with a B2B tag.
  8. Add translations for each language you sell in.
  9. Log in as a test customer through the account page and confirm each change lands in the customer record in the Shopify admin.

For merchants on Plus or with wholesale buyers, see our notes on Shopify Plus customer accounts and B2B customer accounts.

Our perspective

Most account projects we see go wrong in the same way. A merchant picks the app with the longest feature list, installs it on the live store and discovers later that half the features duplicate tools they already own. We think the better order is data first: decide what you need to know about a customer, store it in Shopify metafields, then build the page that collects and shows it.

That is why AccountCraft keeps data inside Shopify and uses only official extensions. It is a narrower product than a suite, on purpose. A customer who edits their own details, manages consent and keeps a wishlist is a customer who comes back, and the merchant ends up with cleaner data without extra systems to maintain.

We also think merchants should treat consent as an ongoing responsibility, not a feature to tick off. An app can help record and honor choices. Deciding what your business must do under the law is yours, ideally with professional advice.

— Ivan Signorile

Try AccountCraft free

AccountCraft has a free plan, and the paid plans, Pro and Plus, are billed through Shopify. For current pricing, check the listing. You can read about the plans on the AccountCraft site or see what to expect when New Customer Accounts arrive. When you are ready, install AccountCraft free from the Shopify App Store.

FAQ

Is Custlo a bad app?

No. Its listing shows a high rating and a broad feature set. It is a suite, so it suits merchants who want loyalty-style extras in the account page. If you need only editable data, consent and a wishlist, a focused builder may be simpler.

Can I switch from another account app to AccountCraft without losing customer data?

It depends on where the old app stored the data. If it wrote to customer metafields, you can bind AccountCraft fields to the same metafields. If the data sits in the vendor’s own database, ask that vendor for an export first. Test on a development store before you touch the live one.

Does using AccountCraft make my store GDPR compliant?

No, and no app can. AccountCraft helps you collect, record and honor customer consent through Shopify’s customer privacy APIs. Compliance remains your responsibility as the data controller, so talk to a qualified privacy professional about your own obligations.

Do I need a developer or theme edits?

No. AccountCraft uses official Customer Account UI extensions and a visual builder, so there is no code and no theme change. Your theme is not involved anyway, because New Customer Accounts are hosted by Shopify.

Can I go back to legacy customer accounts if the migration goes wrong?

Shopify’s community guidance describes a 30-day window to revert. Reverting restores the setting but not customizations that were removed. That is why we recommend testing on a development store or theme copy first. Our post on restoring legacy UX in 30 days covers the details.

Sources